
Freshwater or saltwater — it’s the age-old fishing debate that sparks plenty of passion wherever anglers gather. Is it the serenity of casting across a glassy dam at dawn, chasing bass or Murray cod? Or the thrill of standing on a windswept beach, rod bent against the power of a surging snapper or tailor in the surf? Both offer their own kind of magic, and ask any keen fisho and you’ll likely get a very firm opinion.
It’s a surprisingly controversial topic. Many anglers grow up fishing one style and stick with it for life — freshwater fans swear by the calm, technique and connection to inland waterways, while saltwater devotees chase bigger species, bigger fights and that unmistakable ocean energy. Loyalty runs deep, and friendly arguments are part of the culture.
So, we decided to settle it (or at least stir the pot a little). After surveying thousands of fishers across NSW and beyond, the verdict came in loud and clear:
But before freshwater fans hang up their rods, let’s dive into what makes each style so compelling, and why the debate is far from over.

Yep, something about fishing on NSW's stunning coastline claims top spot for fishing.

Explore easy family walks near Bonny Hills and Port Macquarie, including rainforest boardwalks, coastal...

Discover the best markets on the Coffs Coast, from Coffs Harbour and Sawtell to Woolgoolga, Bellingen and Dorrigo....

Discover Aboriginal cultural experiences across NSW, from guided walks and bush tucker tours to art,...

Discover the best Byron Bay markets, from weekly farmers markets to monthly favourites....

Discover dog-friendly beaches, parks and off-leash areas in the Northern Rivers NSW, from Ballina to Byron Bay....

Discover easy, family-friendly walks in Byron Bay and Brunswick Heads, from coastal tracks to riverside...